Home > Biology, Uncategorized > The simple idea

The simple idea

There is one idea in science, that is unquestionably the simplest but at the same time, explains so many things that we see around daily, that it forms the backbone of an entire field of science: Biology. That idea is evolution.

Everybody has heard of evolution, and would readily say that it means we came from monkeys. But I have a suspicion, that not everybody understands it well. That suspicion, comes from the fact that, I did not understand it, till a few years back. You might say, “neither do I understand E=mc2, even though I have heard about it. So why does it matter knowing evolution?”. But what is different about evolution by natural selection is that, this is an idea, which, once you learn it, will make you feel, “Oh! I could have thought of that myself”. The basic premise is so extraordinarily simple and straightforward. I bet you cant say that about E=mc2.

Evolution by Natural Selection can be explained in 3 points.

1. Features are inherited from parents to offspring while reproduction.

2. Some of these features might vary a little, due to random changes, called mutations, while copying DNA from parent to child. The DNA is the information passed on from parent to child which contains the genetic instructions for building an individual from a single cell.

3. The changes in features (as a result of change in DNA due to mutations) might be beneficial or detrimental to the ability of the individual to survive and reproduce. Individuals whose DNA has changed “positively”, will lead to that individual surviving better in its environment than the others whose DNA has not changed or whose DNA has changed for the worse. Since it is these changed individuals who will survive better, and will have more children, their DNA (inherited from the parents along with the beneficial change) will start spreading through the population.

A hypothetical example: If the previous points sounded a bit vague, imagine a species of deer in a forest. One of the most important things it has to do is to run away from predators, like Cheetah, as quickly as possible, lest it becomes their food. Now the speed and the stamina that the deer possesses while running, is crucial to ensure that it outruns that its predator and survive. Imagine 10 sibling deers out of which there are 2 deers A and B who have undergone changes in DNA while it was being copied from its parents. The rest have exactly the same running genes as its parents, and they run more or less at the same speed of their parents. But A’s DNA underwent a random change (or mutation) (possibly due to errors while copying the DNA from parent to child similar to the way we make mistakes while copying a page of text to another page). Also assume that this change in DNA plays a crucial role in running and helps A to run faster than its parents. Similarly, assume B’s DNA too underwent a random change, but its change was for the worse. That is, its change has led to its running slower than its parents.

In such a scenario it is obvious that when a Cheetah notices these siblings playing together and starts chasing them, there is a very high chance that it is B, that will die first. A and the rest being faster than B (since A has had a positive change, and the rest did NOT have the negative change that B had in its DNA) will survive. In a similar way, after B’s death, A will have a higher chance of survival among the remaining 9. Hence, A has the maximum chance to live to become an adult and reproduce. And while A reproduces, it will pass on its modified faster running gene to all its children. If this change in DNA is crucial and significant enough, then after many generations, all the members of this species in this forest will have the faster running gene, simply because of the fact that anybody who does not have it, will be the first one to fall prey to the Cheetah.

This example captures the essence of Evolution by Natural Selection. Evolution tells us that all the species that exist today have branched off from one single instance of life that was created about 3,500,000,000 (3.5 billion) years ago (as per today’s evidence). Natural selection is the process where nature selects which genes survive. In our example the individual with the faster running gene will survive, since nature, in the form of a Cheetah, decides which of the different varieties of genes live. It is the survival of the genes that is crucial since even though the individual will eventually die, its genes will continue to exist since its children will now have the same genes.

In the above example, the Cheetahs too will possibly undergo evolution since they too need to run faster to capture food. Otherwise they will die of starvation. But let the example not make you think that the expression “Survival of the fittest” is only about running, fighting and other such macho features. Fitness includes everything that enables the individual to survive and pass on its genes. Let us look at a real life example where evolution by natural selection has been observed directly.

A real life example of selection: The peppered moth, is a very common example given to demonstrate how selection works. It is a light coloured moth with black spots. In England, there used to be many such white moths which survived well, since they lived on trees covered with Lichens (a composite of fungus and algae), and hence were very well camouflaged. This prevented the predators from finding the moths. Look at the pictures of a white peppered moth and the Lichens below, to see how easy it would have been for the moths to hide from the predators on Lichen covered trees. But when Industrial revolution happened, the Lichens were killed due to the soot that came from the industries and the trees too were covered by the black soot. This meant that the white moths could not camouflage themselves and were easily found and eaten by their predators. Now because of the soot, black moths began to survive well, since they were camouflaged well against the black trees, and soon the area was full of black moths. The black moths were previously at a disadvantage since predators can find them easily. At that time nature (the predators) chose black peppered moths for consumption, but now it was the turn of the white peppered moths. This is a clear example of how selection works. A curious thing about this episode is that the story did not end there. After environmental regulations came in, white moths have again flourished.

Speciation: You might still say, “This might explain how white moths evolve into black moths, but they are all still moths, right? How can this explain the enormous variety of life that we see around. It is easy to see how features within a species might change like a cheetah or a deer running faster than its peers. But How do a cheetah and deer come about? How do different species come about?”. Speciation (how species come about) is an important field of Biology. But we can easily see how the previous examples can be extended to see how species evolve. And for that let us consider a few members of a species, say rats, that has been introduced into a new island where no rats existed before. Being a new island, the conditions might be drastically different from where they lived previously. Let us say that one of the changes in conditions is that it is very cold. Thus if one of the children of the pioneering rats, has slightly more fur than the rest, then it might survive better, and have more children thus producing more rats with fur. The ones without fur will have lesser chance of surviving. Thus, over many generations rats might evolve fur. Another change in condition could be that there could be lesser predators here, which could mean that they would rather spend their energy on other things like finding food and reproducing, rather than running around avoiding being food themselves. Thus rats that will have lesser speed will survive better, since for them the effort spent of running could be spent on something else more useful for their new environment. Another change in condition could be that the island could be full of water-bodies, and hence some rats which can survive a bit longer in water, might have a better chance of catching a fish for food. Thus slowly, over generations, the rats that survive longer in water might have better chances of surviving. To move around in water, they might start evolving fin like things. And so on. Thus a rat with fur, of a bigger size, with fins and that can survive in water will become completely different from the rats that were introduced first into the island. Thus a new species is created. This is just an example, that I came up with, for understanding how species could evolve.

Gradual change: Note that in the example above, one single rat does not grow fur or start swimming in its own lifetime. The change happens over generations. Change is for the species not for the individual. Moreover, an ordinary rat does not give birth to a new species of rat. At every stage of reproduction, the children vary only very slightly from the parent. It is only if you look at the starting and ending products, that you will see the drastic change. Evolution of every species is also the same. A monkey like ancestor does not give birth to a human being overnight. No individual of a species gives birth to an individual of another species. Features change very slowly, gradually. So gradually, that at no stage can you say that the offspring is different from the parent.

If this sounds weird, imagine that since your birth, your doting parents had taken photographs of you every day and arranged them chronologically in a flip book (like the flip books I used to see when in school, where you can see a batsman playing cover drive. Here is an example.) you can see yourself growing up in front of your eyes.

If you compare each page of the your life’s flip book with the previous one, you will never be able to say that on this particular day you have changed a lot from the previous day. Every day’s photo seems to the same as the previous day’s.   But over a 60-70 year period, the amount of change that can accrue is unbelievable. There is no clear delineation from a child to an adult to an old person. What we know is that at 5 years one is a child, at 30, definitely an adult, and at 70, an old person. But when exactly does one become an adult from a child, is tough to say.

In the same way, it is tough to say when the monkey like ancestor become a human being, or to answer who was the first human being (can you tell me the first day when you were an adult?) or the first chimpanzee, the first dinosaur or any species for that matter. But there is one example which clearly explains the impossibility of drawing boundaries between species.

Thus we are, through a continuous unbroken series of lineage, connected to the first life form that existed about 3.5 billion years ago. And each individual living today (including the whales, the lizards, the plants, the bacteria, the fungi, the peppered moth, the lichens) you can trace your relationship, in exactly the same way as you can trace it for your close human cousins. We are all cousins, (with varying degrees of removal) literally. Take any two individuals, and they would have had a common ancestor some time back (you and your brother’s common ancestors are your parents, you and your first cousin’s are your grand parents and so on).

Given two species, this website, TimeTree, can tell you when the common ancestor between the two species lived (Mya stands for Million years ago, which is the unit used in the website). You can spend quite a bit of your time, finding common ancestors.

This idea was that of Charles Robert Darwin and Alfred Russell Wallace, who came to these conclusions independently. Isn’t it wonderful to know that the mosquito you just killed is your cousin, and so is the okra that you just cut for your lunch (as I once told my mom)? And all this knowledge from the simple idea that those that are better at surviving, survive. Neat, isn’t it??

  1. Sriram
    November 14, 2010 at 17:05

    Intesreting read. Just would like tok point out one other thing that I read some where else that led me to say’ why didn’t i think of this?’. In order to survive a predator, you need not be fater than the ptedator, but you need to be fater than the slowest member in your herd! wow why didn’t I think of this?!!!!

    • November 14, 2010 at 21:32

      True. I have also heard of that. It is a principle that comes up day to day in our life. And one on which the Tamil movie Ramanaa is based. Where the most corrupt person is killed in each government department. The idea is that you dont need to be clean. You only need to be less corrupt than the most corrupt. And that will save your skin 🙂

  2. November 15, 2010 at 10:04

    I just noticed that I have mentioned something in the post, without explaining it. That was a mistake. It is the sentence “But there is one example which clearly explains the impossibility of drawing boundaries between species.” I will do the explaining in one of the future posts.

  3. ramv
    November 18, 2010 at 20:45

    I simply enjoyed reading it. Waiting to read more of your blogs..

  1. December 25, 2010 at 15:29
  2. February 11, 2012 at 16:04
  3. August 6, 2012 at 08:30
  4. August 6, 2012 at 08:34

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: